Samsung Galaxy A51
The biggest of the phones is a $399 bargain, with a beautiful 6.5-inch screen the size of the $1,099 iPhone Pro Max, and even larger than the $999 6.2-inch Samsung Galaxy S20. . You get a second lens with the camera, which the rivals don’t have. And while that’s a plus, Samsung tends to over-saturate your photos, so if that’s a problem, and you want to remain in the Android family, you’ll want to look at the Pixel 4A.
Google Pixel 4A
The best bargain in smartphone land, at $349, the Google phone is an Android flagship with a 5.8-inch screen, fast processor, and a terrific one-lens camera that can take some pretty amazing night photos in the dark. Plus there are add-ons like the ability to add live captions to both homemade videos and ones you watch on YouTube, and an instant transcription service using Google’s voice recording app. The Pixel 4A is clearly the best Pixel phone Google has made, one so good, I think if the line had launched with this model, Google would have been able to turn Pixel into a mass market brand. Google’s market share is under 1%, while most phones sold in the United States are from Apple and Samsung.
Apple iPhone SE
This is the Apple phone for those who didn’t like bigger phones, with a 4.7-inch screen, and yearn for the classic iPhone, one with a Home button for navigation, Touch ID instead of Face ID, and a headphone jack. Apple’s nod to modernity is a powerful A13 processor, the same one that’s in the current top of the line iPhones. It’s classic in every sense, but as powerful as the latest iPhone. If you prefer living in an iPhone world to Android, this is the phone for you.
5G … a concern?
None of these phones are compatible with the new, faster 5G networks. However, know that in our tests, true national 5G service that isn’t spotty or as fast as advertised is still at least a year away, if not longer. So you won’t be missing anything now by waiting.
Which one is best for you? It depends whether you prefer Android or iPhone. I’d choose the Pixel 4A over the Galaxy because I’m not a fan of Samsung bloatware or the somewhat over-saturation of photos, (notice how the oranges below are “orange orange” in the words of the old Trix rabbit, compared to just orange on the Pixel and iPhone) but these are minor quibbles. I could easily live with either.
On a specs basic, you’d have to go with the A51, for the bigger screen and second camera lens. But if money’s tight, the Pixel 4A is fantastic. As is the SE. You couldn’t go wrong with any of these phones.