Individuals looking for a sensible thermostat in 2020 nonetheless have solely two major choices value contemplating: a Nest thermostat versus an Ecobee thermostat. Each stay unparalleled in vitality financial savings and smarts, however Ecobee hasn’t launched a brand new thermostat for the reason that fifth Gen Ecobee SmartThermostat with Voice Management in mid-2019, whereas Nest has shaken issues up with a brand-new, bargain-priced Nest Thermostat. Each will minimize down in your vitality invoice, so we’ll aid you resolve if the extra clever Ecobee mannequin is value the additional cash.
Nest Thermostat vs Ecobee Sensible Thermostat: Sensible options and sensible sensors
In contrast to the Nest Studying Thermostat, neither the brand new Nest Thermostat nor the Ecobee SmartThermostat can mechanically generate a heating and cooling schedule based mostly in your habits. You may should construct your individual customized schedule in every gadget’s app. But each thermostats do have varied clever studying instruments for bettering your vitality effectivity.
We’ll begin with what each units can do. Both thermostat will detect whenever you’ve left residence and mechanically flip down your HVAC vitality use. Every gadget’s app has a scheduling instrument for pre-planning dips and rises in vitality utilization that you will construct your self. After that, you will obtain recommendations from each apps telling you which of them components of your schedule might be improved — although you may at all times select to disregard these recommendations for the sake of consolation.
That principally sums up what the Nest Thermostat can do, with one necessary exception: it now options HVAC monitoring, which means it is going to observe how shortly your system will warmth or cool your private home and warn you in case your system seems to be getting much less efficient.
Ecobee will mechanically keep away from peak vitality utilization to avoid wasting you cash, precooling or preheating your own home when it will not price as a lot.
Ecobee’s thermostat has extra to supply, because of its free Eco+ improve. For starters, it has a Time of Use characteristic that takes into consideration native surge pricing on electrical energy: If it will get costlier at 3 p.m., your Ecobee will preemptively calm down your private home earlier than 3 p.m., then use much less vitality as soon as the worth goes up. Equally, you may join Neighborhood Power Financial savings, which is able to detect when your native energy grid is beneath pressure and cut back your vitality utilization accordingly. It additionally has a Feels Like perform that takes humidity into consideration when adjusting your private home temperature.
You get a clearer image of your private home’s precise temperature with an Ecobee SmartThermostat. In contrast to the Nest Thermostat, which may solely sense the temperature close by itself, your Ecobee will ship with a SmartSensor within the field that you would be able to place in one other room in the home for a clearer studying. Plus, you should purchase an additional two-pack for $65 that may unfold its gaze even additional.
Sensor assist is why we rated the Ecobee SmartThermostat because the greatest sensible thermostat for a number of zones, and why it is disappointing that the brand new Nest Thermostat dropped assist for its sensible sensors that work with the Nest Studying and E Thermostats.
Nest Thermostat vs Ecobee Sensible Thermostat: Do you want one other sensible speaker?
There is a cause why, at full worth, the Ecobee SmartThermostat is almost double that of the Nest Thermostat: It is a sensible thermostat and an Alexa sensible speaker bundled into one four-inch gadget. In our sibling web site iMore’s evaluation of the SmartThermostat, they described the far-field microphones as “surprisingly efficient, selecting up Alexa instructions from prolonged distances, and the speaker, whereas not the best high quality, is sufficient to ship simply identifiable responses.”
The Ecobee SmartThermostat has a 1.5GHz quad-core CPU with 4GB of flash reminiscence that makes it fast to deal with your queries or carry out different duties. It has an LED strip that glows blue when listening to your instructions and crimson when the microphone is turned off. It might even play your Spotify playlists via the audio system!
Ecobee’s built-in Alexa is a wonderful characteristic, however think about whether or not you want a speaker wherever your HVAC wires are positioned.
Your query ought to be whether or not you want any of those options, and it primarily relies upon upon the place you will be putting in this gadget. Is your present thermostat in a hallway the place it will be awkward to face and ask for a climate forecast or hearken to music? Or is it in the lounge, the place you already personal an Alexa speaker? You would definitely buy a Nest Thermostat and Echo 4th Gen sensible speaker for across the identical worth because the Ecobee and get higher audio high quality.
You should not essentially keep away from shopping for the Ecobee SmartThermostat should you do not want an Alexa-compatible thermostat. It additionally works with Google House, Apple HomeKit, and IFTTT instructions, so it ought to hyperlink up with whichever sensible residence you like.
However should you do not want mics in your thermostat, you can think about the Nest Thermostat or Ecobee3 Lite as an alternative — each of which work with Amazon and Google sensible audio system for a cheaper price. For instance, we like how the Nest Thermostat might be managed by our different Google Assistant audio system or sensible shows utilizing Google House Routines, reminiscent of setting a selected temperature whenever you say “Good morning”, “I am residence”, or “Good night time”.
Nest Thermostat vs Ecobee Sensible Thermostat: Set up and compatibility
The best cause to decide on the Nest Thermostat versus the Ecobee SmartThermostat is that if your HVAC system is just appropriate with one or the opposite. Verify the Nest compatibility checker and Ecobee compatibility checker to make sure before you purchase both. Anybody with a high-voltage system (110, 120 or 240 volts) will not be capable of set up any Nest or Ecobee thermostat.
Verify the Nest and Ecobee compatibility checkers earlier than buying both thermostat.
Neither sensible thermostat requires a C wire to work, which is not the case with loads of thermostats. With Ecobee, it is because the thermostat ships with an influence extender package (PEK) that primarily takes the place of a C wire throughout set up. With Nest, it is because the thermostat was designed to make use of lower than 1 kWh/month, so it should not even want the C wire as a main energy supply.
Putting in each units ought to be utterly easy. iMore’s reviewer was capable of set up the Ecobee in 20 minutes by following together with the in-app directions, whereas the Nest Thermostat additionally has app directions that are not alleged to take greater than a half-hour to observe.
Our solely concern is that many customers have reported incessant issues with the Nest Studying Thermostat with out a C Wire, reminiscent of unusual clicking or thumping noises or different errors. We’re unsure as of but whether or not these issues will stick with the brand new Nest Thermostat.
Nest Thermostat vs Ecobee Sensible Thermostat: Show, controls, and specs
Voice instructions and app controls apart, you will usually merely stroll as much as your thermostat and alter the temperature. So think about what sort of contact command you’d desire to perform this.
With the brand new Nest Thermostat, it has a contact strip on the fitting aspect of the thermostat; you slide your finger up and right down to rotate via your decisions after which faucet your finger to pick out one thing. As for the Ecobee SmartThermostat, it contains a conventional touchscreen.
Other than being a touchscreen, the Ecobee show additionally has extra pixels (320 x 480) than the Nest (240 x 320), although a part of this stems from the Ecobee being an inch longer in diameter. Additionally it is a full-color show, although by default it will likely be black. That differs from the Nest Thermostat, which has a mirrored IPS lens that is available in a couple of vibrant colour choices.
For the entire different differing details about these two sensible thermostats, you may verify our detailed spec desk under:
|Nest Thermostat||Ecobee SmartThermostat|
|Colours||Snow, Sand, Fog, Charcoal||Black entrance with white sides|
|Trim Plate||Bought individually||Included with buy|
|HVAC Compatibility||85% of techniques
Most 24V heating and cooling techniques
|Fuel, Oil, Electrical, Twin-fuel
Warmth Pump (4H/2C)
Humidifier, Dehumidifier, Ventilator, HRV or ERV
|Show||2.4-inch IPS LCD with mirrored lens
|3.5 in. full-color LCD touchscreen
|Power Star Licensed||Sure||Sure|
|Distant temperature sensors||No||Sure|
|Guide temperature modifications||Contact strip on aspect||Contact display|
|Recommends schedule changes||Sure||Sure|
|App connectivity||Google House||Ecobee|
|Sensible House connectivity||Alexa & Google Assistant||Apple HomeKit, Amazon Alexa, Google House, Samsung SmartThings, IFTTT|
|Energy||Varied HVAC system wires, 2 AAA battery backup||Wired 24VAC via terminals C and Rc; Energy Extender Equipment|
|Wi-Fi||802.11b/g/n 2.4 GHz, 802.11a/n 5 GHz Wi-Fi||802.11 b/g/n @ 2.4GHz, 802.11 a/n/ac @ 5GHz|
Nest Thermostat vs Ecobee Sensible Thermostat: Which must you purchase?
Whichever sensible thermostat you resolve to purchase, you will begin saving cash immediately in your vitality invoice. You’ll be able to set up both thermostat your self in lower than an hour, and every gadget has AI algorithms for figuring out all of the areas the place you are losing cash. Each have helpful automated instruments, although the Eco+ suite of options are notably superior. Ecobee is costlier, however you might be able to snag one for a significant vacation low cost.
Who ought to choose the Ecobee SmartThermostat? Individuals with giant houses who need particular room temperature knowledge; followers of sensible audio system and Alexa particularly, who do not have already got a sensible speaker in the identical room because the thermostat; or anybody who commonly makes use of IFTTT applets or Apple HomeKit.
Who ought to choose the Nest Thermostat? Anybody on a funds; those that need a extra trendy thermostat so as to add a splash of colour on their wall; homeowners of older houses which can be frightened about their HVAC well being; or folks involved about privateness, who do not like all gadget with a built-in mic of their residence.
Doubles as a sensible speaker
Eco+ sensible financial savings
For a high-quality thermostat that has built-in voice controls, clever temperature shifts based mostly on relative vitality prices throughout the day, and a dependable LCD touchscreen, follow Ecobee’s flagship thermostat.
Multicolor mirrored lenses
Works with Alexa and Google Assistant
For a brand new gadget that will not break your funds and can look trendy in your wall, the Nest Thermostat is a stable purchase. It is going to poke and prod you into saving cash in your vitality invoice, safeguard your HVAC system and mechanically observe when everybody leaves residence.
We could earn a fee for purchases utilizing our hyperlinks. Study extra.